17 Top Selling Makeup Shops On Etsy [2025]
Here are the best shops to find cruelty free and artisan makeup on Etsy. There are plenty of original artisan makeup shops that can be found on Etsy. And the beauty and skin care community over there is growing all the time.
Many makeup lovers everywhere have switched completely over to Etsy for their beauty and makeup needs. It’s so easy to try new and premium makeup products from beauty brands from all around the world.
And the good news is that there are many shops that provide natural, high end makeup, vegan skin care and beauty products.
best makeup shops on etsy
The beauty industry has grown tremendously over recent years, and it’s no surprise there are many handmade makeup products that you can buy on Etsy.
Handcrafted & artisan makeup and beauty products are exactly what many people are looking for to help with their makeup and skin care routines, like using a charcoal face mask.
These smaller shops on Etsy provide excellent customer service and make their beauty products in small batches.
Let’s go through some beauty and makeup shops on Etsy together.
1. Moonrise Creek
As well as their commendable collection of apothecary products, the makeup items in this store are handmade in small batches and take the Earth into consideration when being manufactured.
Making products in small batches like this ensures the best quality and attention to detail, whilst also guaranteeing that your product is much fresher.
2. Dab Herb Makeup
This makeup shop on Etsy offers vegan makeup that is completely plant based. We are totally getting a vibe from their organic cream eye shadows as well as the gorgeous face luminizer creams.
No matter what you choose from this shop, you are going to love trying their products just like their 30,000+ customers.
3. Erzulie Cosmetics
If you have ever wanted to organic liquid foundation then head on over to Erzulie Cosmetics. They also make skin brightening serum and beauty products that are organic and formulated with plant oils like jojoba, carrot seed oil and argan oil.
4. Fierce Magenta
If you’re on the hunt for some affordable but high-quality lip products, this store is very popular and will supply you with any color product you’d like.
They also sell eye shadows, too, giving you the perfect opportunity to spice up your current collection with some fun pigments.
5. Blinking Owl Acres
What we love about this shop is their line of herbal oil cleanses and organic lipsticks with natural pigments.
You can use their lipsticks as cheek color too and since they are made with nourishing ingredients you will look fresh for hours.
Blinking Owl Acres is a holistic makeup & body care company. It is also our Permaculture-based homestead in the Lost Pines ecosystem of Bastrop County, TX.
6. Zerra And Co
Visit this shop for naturally clean skincare & cruelty-free cosmetics like vegan mascara and lotion bars.
One of their top selling beauty items is their tinted lip balms made with natural oils.
7. Foraged Fields
If you’re following a vegan lifestyle, or vegan products interest you, this store may take your fancy, promoting all of it’s organic makeup products.
They’ve got anything you need to build your makeup bag, and it’s all food grade and plant based.
8. KMMS
Mineral powders are great to use on your face and eyes, and the ones from this store are extremely affordable and come in any color you can think of.
I also love that they have some fantastic gift sets for that makeup lover. This shop is definately on my gift list for this year!
9. Olive Blossom Soap
For the most amazing brush cleaner that lasts a long time, visit Olive Blossom Soaps. It’s recommended to clean your makeup brushes at least once a week to keep them free of nasties and this soap is super easy to use.
10. Simplicity cosmetics
This is the place to go if you’re looking for mineral makeup of the highest quality. Their mineral makeup is organic and it would make a great gift idea for any person who has an eye for cosmetics.
11. Little Lilly Shop
If your little loves to play with makeup then check out this shop’s pretend makeup collection. They make everything from mini glitter eyeshadow pallets to pretend nail polish.
12. Bare Natur-ALL
Animal testing is something that most people like to avoid when purchasing new beauty products, and the ones from this store are free from animal derived ingredients.
Their products are top sellers on Etsy and I especially want to try their pink holographic lipstick and eyelash serum.
13. Borne Cosmetics
These handcrafted cosmetics are made with the finest quality ingredients right here in the USA.
They offer free custom blend consultations, so you can get a product tailored just for you. If you need an order quickly or have a question over the weekend, you can reach out to them. Custom orders take a little longer but customers say it’s totally worth it.
14. Crush Cosmetics
If you’re looking for more vegan makeup, here is the perfect fusion between cruelty-free beauty and colorful, inspirational eyeshadows and more.
Their products have buttery formulas in colors so stunning, you’ll want more!
15. Handmade by Avo
And now that you have all of your makeup, you are going to need some handmade cotton remover pads. This shop has lots of pretty patterns to choose from to suit your own personality.
16. Aromi
Formulated from scratch in small batches, this cosmetics brand offers gorgeous perfume, lip gloss and more. You’ll find eye-catching colors and pigments perfect for any skin tone or occasion.
Plus the stellar range of scents formulated with natural fragrances like vanilla and jasmine will tantalize your senses. A beginner or a professional makeup artist will find the latest stunning shades.
17. Pure Intentions LA
These products are completely free from alcohol, synthetic fragrances, and artificial colorants, making them a great choice for anyone with sensitive skin.
I love that they focus on clean ingredients without unnecessary additives. It’s nice to know you’re using something that’s gentle and good for your skin while still being high quality!
Thanks for reading!
I hope you found this list of makeup shops helpful in your search for the perfect brands for you!
Next, head on over and see who made the list of best reusable makeup remover pads.
