25 Top Selling Etsy Jewelry Shops [2025]
Here are the best Etsy jewelry shops. Looking for unique and high-quality handmade jewelry? Etsy is home to a wide variety of talented artisans who specialize in creating one-of-a-kind pieces.
If you’re in the market for a stunning statement necklace or a delicate pair of earrings, Etsy has got you covered. To help you navigate the sea of options, we’ve rounded up some of the best jewelry shops on Etsy.
These shops have earned a reputation for crafting beautiful, unique, and high-quality pieces that you won’t find anywhere else. Jewelry is one of the top selling categories on Etsy.
So, without further ado, let’s dive into our top picks for the best jewelry shops on Etsy!
Best Etsy Jewelry Shops
1. Geominimalist
Welcome to this Etsy shop where they specialize in creating unique and beautiful jewelry pieces for your birthday celebrations.
From dainty necklaces to sparkling earrings to statement bracelets, they have something for every style and taste.
Their pieces are expertly crafted with the finest materials and designed to add a touch of elegance to your special day.
2. Sacred And Coveted
If you’re looking for one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces that were created just for the lux shopper in you, then you’ve come to the right place.
Their shop boasts a wide range of stunning jewelry pieces that are truly unique and handmade with love.
From intricate and delicate designs to bold and statement-making pieces, they offer something for everyone. Their jewelry is crafted using only the finest quality materials and has a price to match.
3. Bloom Diamonds
This jewelry shop on Etsy has all the bling you need to upgrade your accessory game – from sparkling diamonds to stunning gold rings and necklaces.
Their pieces are designed to be timeless, so whether you’re dressing up for a special occasion or adding a touch of elegance to your everyday look, their jewelry is something to see for sure.
4. FGem
Looking for unique and customizable jewelry? Look no further than this top-selling Etsy shop for Fine Handmade Personalized Jewelry.
Each piece is crafted with care and attention to detail, making them beautiful and one-of-a-kind.
From minimalist designs to statement pieces, there’s no shortage of options to choose from.
5. Nature’s Opals
Here’s a fantastic Etsy shop which specializes in crafting stunning jewelry from earth-mined opals.
With a vast collection of stunning rings, there’s something for everyone in this shop.
Known for its top-notch quality and beautiful rings, it’s no wonder why this shop continues to be a bestseller on Etsy.
If you are in love with opals, you’re sure to find what you’re looking for at this amazing jewelry shop.
6. Gispan Diamonds
Indulge in the elegance and charm of vintage inspired jewelry at this jewelry shop on Etsy.
Each handcrafted piece boasts a sense of whimsy and sophistication that only comes with the vintage aesthetic.
You’ll find gorgeous rings in white gold, sapphire, flower designs and more that will dazzle and shine.
7. Specimental
As soon as you step into this jewelry shop on Etsy, you’ll feel like you’ve discovered a secret treasure trove. The rustic, natural feel of the rough diamond jewelry is enough to take your breath away.
The intricate details and organic shapes draw you in, and you can’t help but imagine wearing them on romantic dates or dancing under the stars with them on.
8. MS Jewelers
Welcome to a hidden gem on Etsy – the ultimate hub for jewelry lovers. Their jewelry shop offers a dazzling array of options, all thoughtfully crafted to suit every budget and style.
From the understated elegance of minimalist pieces to the intricate beauty of statement necklaces and earrings, you are sure to find something that speaks to your personal flair.
9. Roberto Gold Diamond
Intricate designs, and unique materials come together to create a stunning collection that is sure to impress.
Their casual yet romantic vibe will make you feel right at home while you peruse the endless options like for your Etsy gift giving.
10. Delezhen
As you stroll through the beautifully crafted pieces in this jewelry shop on Etsy, you can’t help but feel the romantic energy that exudes from each piece.
The attention to detail in each piece truly makes it one-of-a-kind.
Some of their top sellers include these handmade family charm necklaces.
11. Porans
Nestled within their virtual shelves are stunning, one-of-a-kind pieces, crafted with love and inspiration drawn from the depths of the ocean.
Their vibe will make you feel right at home while you peruse the endless options from rings to cuffs.
Their jewelry is perfect for those seeking something special, something that will help them feel beautiful and connected to natural elements, no matter where they are in the world.
12. Mu Design Jewelry
Step into this mystical jewelry shop on Etsy and get ready to be enchanted. Here, you’ll find an exquisite collection of handmade esoteric jewelry crafted by an artful and romantic flair.
Every piece is infused with dreamy elements. If you’re in search of a gift idea or a piece that expresses your unique style, this shop has many amazing pieces to choose from.
13. Natural Gems Atelier
Nestled among the plethora of fine jewelry shops on Etsy, there’s one that stands out, and for all the right reasons.
The shop boasts of having the most beautiful natural gemstone jewelry pieces and pearls. The designs are crafted skillfully, resulting in unprecedented beauty.
You’ll fall in love with the intricate designs, the unique color combinations, and the natural beauty of the gemstones.
14. Glamour Jewelry House
Step into this hidden gem of a jewelry shop on Etsy and you’re sure to be delighted by the abundance of unique and thoughtful gift ideas.
From delicate charms to custom initial jewelry, every item in this collection exudes a romantic and whimsical feel.
For those seeking a one-of-a-kind piece from a top selling Etsy store, this shop has some really unique pieces.
15. Olli Jewelry
In a world of mass-produced commercialization, there’s something romantic about owning a piece of jewelry that was created with care and passion for the craft.
Step into this hidden gem of a jewelry shop on Etsy and you’re sure to be delighted by the abundance of unique and thoughtful gift ideas.
From delicate charms to colorful pieces, every item in this collection exudes a romantic and whimsical feel.
16. Wire Tales
Step into the world of wire wrapped jewelry, where every piece is an ode to nature’s brilliance and the wonder of travel.
This Etsy shop has an enchanting collection of handmade jewelry pieces that are sure to make your heart skip a beat.
The mastermind behind the brand has an eye for the small details which make every piece a unique treasure.
17. Antique Animal Jewelry
Each piece of antique jewelry is unlike anything you’ll find anywhere else. These treasures are hard to come by and have a unique story to tell.
From ornate cherub pendants to one of a kind brooches, each piece exudes a sense of romance and mystery.
The jewelry from this shop is the perfect addition to any outfit and will surely spark conversation wherever you go.
18. Rings Of Earth
Here’s a beautifully curated collection of handmade rings that you simply won’t find anywhere else.
They are a jewelry shop that prides themselves on each and every piece they create, from casual to extravagant, all unique in their own way.
The handmade rings come in every style and design you can dream of, all crafted with love and passion. Each piece is carefully crafted with attention to detail.
19. The Wind Opal
Opals are like tiny works of art, with a spectrum of color that shimmers and twirls like a dancer’s dress.
And it’s no wonder they’re some of the top-selling jewelry out there. Opals make a statement, whether you’re wearing them as a necklace, ring, or earrings.
They’re a symbol of love, passion, and fire – perfect for a romantic night out or just to add some pizzazz to your everyday wardrobe.
20. Elise Jewelry US
Moonstone jewelry is the perfect pick for those who want to add a touch of magic to their wedding band.
This captivating gemstone casts a silky-blue hue that is sure to make any heart skip a beat. It is a symbol of new beginnings and marks the coming together of two souls.
Its mystical charm is nothing short of spellbinding and continues to be a favorite among couples.
21. Salon Uber
Butterflies are undoubtedly one of the most beautiful creatures of nature, and what better way to show your admiration for them than with butterfly jewelry?
This delicate and dainty accessory is a perfect gift for the nature lover in your life. The pieces of jewelry from this shop evoke feelings of whimsy and romance.
See our article about butterfly name ideas if you love butterflies.
22. Charlotte Hazel Co
Pressed flower jewelry is a beautiful way to wear a piece of nature with you wherever you go.
It’s perfect for nature lovers who want to bring the beauty of the natural world into their outfits.
Each piece of jewelry is unique, featuring flowers carefully preserved and arranged in a stunning design.
With pressed flower jewelry from this top selling jewelry shop, you can wear a piece of nature and show off your love for the environment in a stylish and romantic way.
23. Otis B Jewelry
When it comes to gift giving, there’s something really special about handmade jewelry.
Maybe it’s because you know that the person who made it put all their time, effort and creativity into creating a one-of-a-kind piece.
Or it’s because handmade jewelry feels personal and unique, unlike something that you could just grab off the shelf at a department store.
No matter the reason, there’s something so romantic and thoughtful about giving handmade jewelry as a gift. It feels meaningful and like a true expression of love and appreciation.
24. Shelley Cooper Jewelry
Sweet Romance Jewelry, a top Etsy shop, consistently offers style, self-expression, and a sense of beauty through its designs.
Shelley Cooper leads the design team in their Los Angeles studio, where each piece is handcrafted with remarkable attention to detail.
Their timeless designs seamlessly blend contemporary fashion with the charm of antique and vintage jewelry, and Sweet Romance Jewelry is also the official designer and manufacturer of the Elvira Jewelry Collection.
25. Mai Minimalist
A top selling jewelry shop, where each piece is a true work of art, meticulously designed and crafted to captivate.
Their collection is a testament to fine quality, showcasing unique and one-of-a-kind creations that stand out from the crowd.
They take great pride in providing impeccable customer service, so that your shopping experience is as exceptional as the jewelry itself.
Tips for buying etsy jewelry
Read Reviews and Ratings:
Take the time to read reviews and ratings from previous customers. This can provide valuable insights into the shop’s reliability, product quality, and customer service. Look for shops with a high number of positive reviews.
Check Shop Policies:
Review the shop’s policies, including shipping, returns, and payment methods. Make sure you understand the shipping times and any potential customs fees if you’re ordering internationally. Clear shop policies indicate a professional and transparent seller.
Ask Questions:
Don’t hesitate to contact the seller if you have any questions or need additional information about a product. A reputable seller should be responsive and willing to provide you with all the details you need.
Examine Product Descriptions:
Thoroughly read product descriptions and examine the provided photos. Look for details about materials, sizes, and any customization options.
Secure Payment:
Use Etsy’s secure payment options, such as Etsy Payments or PayPal, to protect your financial information. Avoid making payments outside of Etsy, as it may be harder to resolve issues if any disputes arise.
In Closing:
There you have it – our top picks for the best handmade jewelry shops on Etsy. Whether you’re shopping for a special occasion or just treating yourself, you’re sure to find something you love from these talented artisans.
Did you find this list of jewelry designers helpful? We hope so!
If you would like to support our blog, we would love it if you could share this article on your social media or link back to us from your own blogs and websites.
Next, check out these fashion ideas for women over 40.
